Philippine Lemon Law: 12 Months or 20,000 km

The Philippine Lemon Law, Republic Act No. 10642, approved 15 July 2014, gives the buyer of a brand new vehicle a way out when the same fault keeps coming back. Two numbers decide whether you are still inside it: 12 months and 20,000 kilometres.

The rights period

Both run from delivery, not from the date of sale, the invoice or the LTO registration. A vehicle delivered in January and driven hard can exhaust the distance limit long before the 12 months are up.

What counts as a lemon

The Act’s word is nonconformity: any defect or condition that substantially impairs the use, value or safety of a brand new motor vehicle, preventing it from conforming to the manufacturer’s or distributor’s standards or specifications, which cannot be repaired.

Four causes are carved out, and they are the seller’s standard defence.

What is a motor vehicle here

Narrower than most people expect. The Act means a self-propelled, 4 wheeled road vehicle designed to carry passengers: sedans, coupes, station wagons, convertibles, pick-ups, vans, SUVs and AUVs.

Excluded outright: motorcycles, delivery trucks, dump trucks, buses, road rollers, trolley cars, street sweepers, sprinklers, lawn mowers, and heavy equipment such as bulldozers, payloaders, graders, forklifts, amphibian trucks and cranes, plus vehicles running only on rails, and tractors, trailers and traction engines used exclusively for agriculture.

Brand new is also a defined term: constructed entirely from new parts, covered by a manufacturer’s express warranty at purchase, never sold or registered with the transport authority, and never operated on any highway in the Philippines or abroad.

The sequence, in order

Getting this order wrong is how claims fail.

1. 4 separate repair attempts by the same manufacturer, distributor, authorised dealer or retailer, for the same complaint, with the nonconformity unresolved. Replacing parts, components or assemblies counts.
2. Written notice to the seller of the unresolved complaint and your intention to invoke Lemon Law rights, inside the rights period. The warranty booklet must state the manner and form this notice takes.
3. A final repair attempt. You bring the vehicle back for one more try.
4. File with the DTI if it is still unresolved.

There is a trap at step 3. If the vehicle is not returned for repair on the same complaint within 30 days from the notice of release following that attempt, the repair is deemed successful. If the problem persists after those 30 days but you are still inside the rights period, you can run the sequence again.

Where it is heard

The DTI has exclusive and original jurisdiction, and the Act sets three mechanisms with their own clocks.

Beyond that, a party may go to the Court of Appeals on certiorari under Rule 65.

Stacked end to end, the published periods after your fourth failed repair run 30 days for the deemed-successful window, then 10 working days of mediation, then 20 working days of adjudication, then 15 days to appeal and 30 days for the Secretary to decide. That is roughly 75 days of calendar periods plus 30 working days of DTI proceedings, and it is arithmetic on the Act’s own figures rather than a timetable it publishes. Arbitration, if both sides agree to it, sits outside those limits entirely.

The cost of establishing whether your complaint is valid is borne jointly by you and the seller while the case runs. If the DTI finds no nonconformity, you are directed to reimburse the seller’s validation costs.

The two remedies

Collateral charges are defined to include the LTO registration fees and other incidental expenses such as insurance on the vehicle, chattel mortgage fees and interest expenses. So a refund is not just the sticker price. The vehicle registration guide covers the fees that fall into that category.

Choosing a higher-value vehicle from the same seller is allowed; you pay the difference.

The deduction you will actually feel

Both remedies are reduced by a reasonable allowance for use, and Section 9 defines it precisely:

twenty percent (20%) per annum deduction from the purchase price, or the product of the distance traveled in kilometers and the purchase price divided by one hundred thousand (100,000) kilometers, whichever is lower.

“Whichever is lower” runs in the consumer’s favour. The distance formula produces the smaller number for a car driven under 20,000 kilometres in its first 12 months, which is most cars inside the rights period, because 20,000 divided by 100,000 is a fifth of the purchase price against a full 20% for a whole year.

Transport while you wait

To compensate for non-usage while the vehicle is under repair and during availment, you are entitled to a reasonable daily transportation allowance covering travel from your residence to your regular workplace or destination and back. It is measured at air-conditioned taxi fare evidenced by official receipt, or an amount agreed between the parties, or a service vehicle at the seller’s option. Disagreements go to the DTI.

Resale disclosure, and the only peso penalty in the Act

If a returned vehicle is put back on the market, the seller must disclose in writing to the next purchaser, before sale or transfer: that the vehicle was returned, the nature of the nonconformity that caused the return, and the vehicle’s condition at the time of transfer. That duty ends once the affected vehicle is sold to the first purchaser.

Note what this does not cover: there is no peso penalty in the Act for refusing a replacement or refund. The remedy there is the DTI order itself.

What this page does not cover

The Act required the DTI to promulgate implementing rules within 90 days of effectivity, and those rules carry the complaint form, the filing fee, the documentary requirements and the DTI office to approach. None of that is in the statute, so none is stated here. The Act took effect 15 days after publication, and nothing in it limits or impairs your rights and remedies under any other law, including the Consumer Act.

For the record on dates, since a vehicle delivered before effectivity is outside the Act: RA 10642 was passed by the Senate on 11 June 2014 and by the House on 10 June 2014, and approved on 15 July 2014. The implementing agency is the DTI as reorganised under the Administrative Code of 1987.

Related

The vehicle registration guide covers the LTO fees that count as collateral charges in a refund, the transfer of ownership guide covers what happens when a vehicle changes hands, and the small claims guide covers the separate court route for money claims that fall outside this Act.

• All guides
• Calculators
• How figures on this site are sourced